Skip to content
International Adviser
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Regions
    • United Kingdom
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • Latin America
  • Industry
    • Tax & Regulation
    • Products
    • Life
    • Health & Protection
    • People Moves
    • Companies
    • Offshore Bonds
    • Retirement
    • Technology
    • Platforms
  • Investment
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Alternatives
    • Multi Asset
    • Property
    • Macro Views
    • Structured Products
    • Emerging Markets
    • Commodities
  • IA 100
  • Best Practice
    • Best Practice News
    • Best Practice Awards
  • Media
    • Video
    • Podcast
  • My IA
    • Events
    • IA Tax Panel
    • IA Intermediary Panel
    • About IA

ANNOUNCEMENT: Read more financial articles on our partner site, click here to read more.

SIGN IN INTERNATIONAL ADVISER

Access full content on the International Adviser site, access your saved articles, control email preferences and amend your account details

[login-with-ajax]
Not Registered?

ESMA finds strong evidence of ‘closet tracker’ funds

By , 2 Feb 16

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) said a study it undertook found that up to 15% of large, actively-managed Ucits equity funds are potentially just tracking the underlying market index.

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) said a study it undertook found that up to 15% of large, actively-managed Ucits equity funds are potentially just tracking the underlying market index.

ESMA said its study had been prompted by a growing number of investigations by national regulatory authorities, complaints from consumer organisations and media attention into so called “closet tracking”.

Misleading claims

At the heart to this problem is an alleged practice in the European investment management industry whereby an asset manager claims to manage their funds in an active manner and charges fees accordingly, but in fact the funds stay very close to a benchmark.

ESMA’s study looked into equity funds domiciled in EU member states that were not categorised as index-tracking UCITS. They also had to have assets under management of more than €50m, have an inception date before 1 January 2005; and management fees of more than 0.65%.

It found more than 2,600 Ucits that met the criteria and was able to retrieve data for 1,251 Ucits sub-funds for the period 2012-2014.

"Fund managers must provide investors with information that is fair, clear and not misleading."

Potential trackers

Esma said that of the funds where less than 60% of the holdings differed from the benchmark and where the overall fund had a tracking error of less than 4% to that benchmark, 15% could be  classified as potentially being closet indexers.

Of funds with an active share of less than 50% and a tracking error of less than 3%, around 7% could be classified as potential closet trackers, ESMA said.

“Investor protection is core to our mission and the preliminary findings raise questions that merit closer analysis,” said ESMA chairman Steven Maijoor.

“Fund managers must provide investors with information that is fair, clear and not misleading. In partnership with national regulators we are taking a closer look into this issue,” he said.

More work needed

Maijoor said ESMA would continue to work with national regulators to determine what actions should be taken as the analysis to date only provided a first indication of whether particular funds are closet index trackers.

Future work will include an active role for ESMA in coordinating further analysis being carried out at the national level. However, it said investigations into particular funds remains under the remit of national authorities as part of their regular supervisory work.

“ESMA considers it important that fund managers take their commitments in disclosure documents seriously. Managers should expect supervisory consequences where evidence for incorrect disclosures is proven,” the supervisor said.

Tags: ESMA | UCITS

Share this article
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
X (Twitter)
Post on X
LinkedIn
Share

Related Stories

  • Companies

    Brooks Macdonald stems outflows as client engagement kicks in

    Europe

    Ancelotti hit with 1 year prison sentence for tax fraud

  • Europe

    Swiss AI specialists targets family offices and HNWIs with new ICAV

    Companies

    JTC completes Citi Trust takeover


NEWSLETTER

Sign Up for International
Adviser Daily Newsletter

subscribe

  • View site map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Published by Money Map Media – part of G&M Media Ltd Copyright (c) 2024.

International Adviser covers the global intermediary market that uses cross-border insurance, investments, banking and pension products on behalf of their high-net-worth clients. No news, articles or content may be reproduced in part or in full without express permission of International Adviser.