Skip to content
International Adviser
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Regions
    • United Kingdom
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • Latin America
  • Industry
    • Tax & Regulation
    • Products
    • Life
    • Health & Protection
    • People Moves
    • Companies
    • Offshore Bonds
    • Retirement
    • Technology
    • Platforms
  • Investment
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Alternatives
    • Multi Asset
    • Property
    • Macro Views
    • Structured Products
    • Emerging Markets
    • Commodities
  • IA 100
  • Best Practice
    • Best Practice Awards
  • Media
    • Video
    • Podcast
  • Directory
  • My IA
    • Events
    • IA Tax Panel
    • IA Intermediary Panel
    • About IA

ANNOUNCEMENT: Read more financial articles on our partner site, click here to read more.

IFA firm fails to get film scheme negligence case dismissed

By Robbie Lawther, 5 May 20

Ex-Premier League footballers Andy Cole and Robbie Savage among the investors

A High Court judge has ruled against a UK financial planning firm’s bid to have a negligence claim tossed out, which was brought by former Premier League football players over a failed film tax relief scheme.

Judge Christopher Nugee dismissed the claims from advice firm Carpenter Rees that the investors, which include ex-footballers Andy Cole, Robbie Savage and Danny Murphy, waited too long to file the law suit.

On 30 April 2020, he denied the summary judgment application filed by the business because it had not proven the investors knew as far back as 2012 that they were losing money as a result of the tax schemes but waited until outside a three-year statute of limitations to bring their claims to court.

The judge said he was persuaded by the footballers’ legal team “that there is a reasonable prospect of the claimants establishing that they did not have the requisite constructive knowledge”, as a result of the letters they were sent in 2012 by companies that promoted the schemes.

“That is sufficient to mean that the application for summary judgment fails,” the judge said in his ruling.

Details

According to court filing; the investors, made up of mostly former English football stars, put their money into film schemes promoted by investment firm Scion and other similarly named corporate entities between 2005 and 2007.

They were persuaded to invest in the Scion Premier film finance schemes, which were promoted as tax efficient, by their IFAs.

These IFAs worked for now-defunct Formation Asset Management, called at the time Kingsbridge Asset Management, which had a particular focus on clients in professional sports.

Between 2005 and 2007, Formation/Kingsbridge were the authorised representatives of IFA firm Carpenter Rees and it is on this legal basis that the footballers’ claims are being made against the business.

Their law suit in 2015 states that they were financially disadvantaged as a result of the advice provided by Formation, and Carpenter Rees was responsible for its actions as an appointed representative.

In December 2019, four of the footballers failed in a bid to pursue two banks which approved loans, ranging between £175,000 and £1.1m, enabling them to invest in the film scheme.

But the judge in that case ruled that they had little chance of success.

Letters

Some of the investors said they did not receive letters during the assumed time period, and those who did said they did not contain enough information to take expert advice.

The judgment said that this meant their “date of knowledge” of the scheme’s failings was less than three years before they filed suit.

In his ruling on 30 April 2020, judge Nugee found in favour of the footballers on all points.

He said: “CRL has not established that there is no reasonable prospect of success on the claims against it, and I will dismiss the application for summary judgment.

“For reasons already given, that means that I will also dismiss the application to strike the claims out.”

Seek financial redress

Jonathan Tickner, partner at Peters & Peters Solicitors, the law firm representing the investors,  said: “The decision of Mr Justice Nugee is welcomed as the court held in favour of the claimants on all issues.

“The claimants now welcome the opportunity to advance the claims to trial to vindicate their interests and seek financial redress”.

International Adviser has contacted financial planning firm Carpenter Rees and DAC Beachcroft, the law firm defending the company, for a comment.

Tags: Film Scheme

Share this article
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
X (Twitter)
Post on X
LinkedIn
Share

Related Stories

  • Emerging Markets

    Aviva Investors launches Emerging Market Debt Opportunities fund

    Tax & Regulation

    UK Budget changes: What advisers need to know about long-term wealth planning

  • A red inked rubber stamp with the word Fail

    Investment

    ‘I invested £250k spinal injury payout in Godwin after asking adviser for low-risk investment – now I’ve lost everything’

    Latest news

    FCA charges Raymond Fieldhouse with money laundering


NEWSLETTER

Sign Up for International
Adviser Daily Newsletter

subscribe

  • View site map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Published by Money Map Media – part of G&M Media Ltd Copyright (c) 2024.

International Adviser covers the global intermediary market that uses cross-border insurance, investments, banking and pension products on behalf of their high-net-worth clients. No news, articles or content may be reproduced in part or in full without express permission of International Adviser. Site managed by Furness Media

polestoto

lahirtoto

warung403

warung403 login

situs warung403

lahirtoto

LAHIRTOTO

LAHIRTOTO LOGIN

lahirtoto

imgstock

Hosting Gambar

Scatter Mahjong Ways 2 Terlihat Berbeda dalam Video Hasil Restorasi Digital, Mengapa Detail Asli Bisa Berubah

Gates of Olympus Ditampilkan melalui Layar dengan Fitur AI Super Resolution, Apa yang Terjadi pada Ketajaman Simbol

Starlight Princess Direkam Menggunakan Mode Sinematik, Mengapa Efek Fokus Bisa Mengaburkan Informasi Penting

Shio Kuda Api dan Makna Kebebasan dalam Cerita Wild Bounty Showdown, Memahami Perbedaan Simbol dan Persepsi

Sweet Bonanza Ditonton melalui Browser dengan Fitur Isolasi Situs, Mengenal Cara Perlindungan Data Bekerja

Mahjong Ways 2 Muncul dalam Video dengan Audio yang Dipercepat, Mengapa Persepsi Durasi Bisa Berubah

Ketika Statistik Gates of Olympus Disajikan dalam Diagram Lingkaran, Apa yang Perlu Diperhatikan saat Membaca Persentase

Zodiak Gemini dan Shio Ayam dalam Konten Wild Bandito, Menelusuri Perbedaan Simbol Komunikasi dan Ketelitian

Mahjong Wins 2 pada Ponsel dengan Fitur RAM Expansion, Mengapa Kapasitas Tambahan Tidak Selalu Membuat Browser Lebih Cepat

Grafik RTP Pragmatic Play Dibuat Menggunakan AI, Mengapa Visualisasi Menarik Belum Tentu Menjamin Data Akurat

ketika mahjong online dikaitkan dengan ramalan nasib mengapa kepercayaan lama muncul kembali di era digital

fenomena mahjong sebagai bahasa pergaulan bagaimana istilah permainan masuk ke percakapan generasi muda

di balik cerita ubin mahjong yang dianggap membawa hoki ada warisan simbol dari masa lalu

game online mahjong dan budaya fan art ketika karakter permainan menjadi inspirasi karya digital

mengapa narasi mahjong mistis mudah viral di internet mengenal pertemuan folklor dan budaya populer

ketika mahjong online menjadi bahan cerita fiksi interaktif bagaimana komunitas membentuk dunia naratif baru

fenomena nama simbol mahjong dalam budaya internet mengapa makna tradisional bisa berubah

mahjong online dan ekonomi kreator bagaimana konten tematik dapat membentuk komunitas digital

antara legenda naga dan dunia mahjong modern mengapa mitologi asia terus menginspirasi hiburan

ketika ai menciptakan ilustrasi mahjong bagaimana membedakan warisan visual asli dari interpretasi mesin

Scatter Hitam Mahjong Ways 2 Terlihat dalam Video Tanpa Timestamp, Mengapa Waktu Kejadian Sulit Dipastikan

Efek Petir Gates of Olympus Tampak Lebih Terang pada Rekaman HDR, Apa yang Sebenarnya Berubah

Starlight Princess Mengalami Perubahan Tampilan saat Browser Diperbesar, Mengenal Pengaruh Zoom terhadap Antarmuka

Shio Kuda Api dan Simbol Perubahan dalam Cerita Wild Bounty Showdown, Menelusuri Makna di Balik Narasi Karakter

Sweet Bonanza Ditonton melalui Layar dengan Fitur Anti-Flicker, Mengapa Kenyamanan Visual Bisa Berbeda

Ketika Screenshot Mahjong Ways 2 Dibagikan Berulang Kali, Bagaimana Kualitas Gambar dan Informasi Bisa Berkurang

Video Gates of Olympus Menampilkan Simbol yang Seolah Berhenti Bersamaan, Mengenal Pengaruh Frame Sampling

Zodiak Scorpio dan Shio Naga dalam Konten Wild Bandito, Mengapa Karakter Kuat Sering Dikaitkan dengan Keberuntungan

Mahjong Wins 2 Dibuka saat Koneksi Berpindah dari WiFi ke Data Seluler, Apa yang Terjadi pada Sesi Browser

Persentase RTP Pragmatic Play Dibandingkan Tanpa Memeriksa Versi Game, Mengapa Kesimpulannya Bisa Keliru

Kasino Online di Tengah Perubahan Cara Mesin Pencari Menampilkan Informasi Digital

Ketika Efek Suara Kasino Digital Memengaruhi Cara Pengguna Mengingat Sebuah Peristiwa

Fenomena Konten Kasino Online yang Diputar Berulang, Mengapa Detail Tertentu Terasa Semakin Meyakinkan

Kasino Digital pada Layar dengan Mode Perlindungan Mata, Ada Perubahan Visual yang Perlu Dipahami

Di Balik Klaim Populer Kasino Online, Ada Perbedaan antara Data Pengamatan dan Bukti Statistik

Mengapa Video Kasino Digital yang Direkam dari Layar Lain Sering Kehilangan Detail Penting

Kasino Online dan Efek Framing, Ketika Cara Informasi Disajikan Mengubah Persepsi Pembaca

Ketika Konten Kasino Digital Diterjemahkan Otomatis, Makna Istilah Teknis Bisa Bergeser

Kasino Online dalam Fenomena Digital Fatigue, Saat Terlalu Banyak Konten Mengurangi Ketelitian

Memahami Pengaruh Urutan Informasi terhadap Cara Pengguna Menilai Konten Kasino Digital