Skip to content
International Adviser
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • Regions
    • United Kingdom
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • Latin America
  • Industry
    • Tax & Regulation
    • Products
    • Life
    • Health & Protection
    • People Moves
    • Companies
    • Offshore Bonds
    • Retirement
    • Technology
    • Platforms
  • Investment
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Alternatives
    • Multi Asset
    • Property
    • Macro Views
    • Structured Products
    • Emerging Markets
    • Commodities
  • M&A Deals
  • Best Practice
    • Best Practice News
    • Best Practice Awards
  • Media
    • Video
    • Square Mile Research
  • My IA
    • Events
    • Directory
    • IA Tax Panel
    • IA Intermediary Panel
    • About IA

ANNOUNCEMENT: Read more financial articles on our partner site, click here to read more.

SIGN IN INTERNATIONAL ADVISER

Access full content on the International Adviser site, access your saved articles, control email preferences and amend your account details

[login-with-ajax]
Not Registered?

In China, passive outdoes active

By International Adviser, 25 Jul 16

Over the trailing three years, more passive China equity funds than actively-managed ones had returns of 20% or more, according to FE data.

Over the trailing three years, more passive China equity funds than actively-managed ones had returns of 20% or more, according to FE data.

A lot has happened in China over the last three years. The sustained slowdown in GDP, inclusion of the RMB in the IMF’s currency basket, retail market volatility and surprise devaluation of the currency last year are just a few of the events that sent China’s markets on a wild ride.

Was an investor better off with an active or passive fund?

FE data suggests that investment in a passive vehicle would have been the better strategy. Twenty Chinese equity ETFs and tracker funds that are available for sale in Hong Kong generated a return of 20% or more over the past three years. Returns ranged from 23.8% to 55.9%, FE data shows. 

That compares to 13 actively-managed Chinese equity funds that had a three-year return of 20% or more, ranging between 20.7% and 80%.

The top passive vehicle was the Harvest-MSCI China A Index ETF with a 55.9% three-year return.

 Source: FE

The Allianz China A-Shares Fund was the top actively-managed fund during the period, with an 80% return.

Source: FE

Active vs passive

A look at the sector weightings of the top-performing active and passive funds shows that they have similar sector allocations, which include financials, industrials and consumer products.

Sector weightings of the two funds:

Allianz (Actively managed) %  Harvest (ETF) %
Financials  32.3  Financials  29.05 
Industrials  20.4 Industrials  20.1
Consumer Products  19.3 Consumer Products  15.84
Telecom, Media, Technology  12.2 Basic Materials 11.7
Basic Materials 10.0 Telecom, Media, Technology  11.0
Healthcare 5.7 Healthcare 6.9
    Utilities 3.9
    Money Market 1.5

Source: FE; funds’ factsheet

While the Allianz fund had the higher return of the two, it also came with higher fees than the ETF, eroding the return to the investor. 

The Allianz product has an annual management charge (AMC) of 2.25% maximum. That is far higher than the top-performing passive fund, the Harvest ETF, with an AMC of 0.6% maximum. 

Although investors in the Allianz fund can point to its outperformance, the same cannot be said for investors in the other top four actively-managed funds. They all significantly underperformed their passive counterparts over the three-year period, as the charts above show.

Tags: Active Investing | Allianz | China | ETF | Passive Investing

Share this article
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
X (Twitter)
Post on X
LinkedIn
Share

Related Stories

  • Equities

    Washington’s risky fiscal bet

    Spain

    Equities

    Returns from Spain are anything but plain as IBEX35 gains

  • Asia

    ASIC cancels Australian financial services licence of Brite Advisors

    Asia

    Utmost Wealth Solutions sees strong inflows in ‘transformational’ year


NEWSLETTER

Sign Up for International
Adviser Daily Newsletter

subscribe

  • View site map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Published by Money Map Media – part of G&M Media Ltd Copyright (c) 2024.

International Adviser covers the global intermediary market that uses cross-border insurance, investments, banking and pension products on behalf of their high-net-worth clients. No news, articles or content may be reproduced in part or in full without express permission of International Adviser.